Topic Five Discussion Twenty-Seven:  The Partitions of Poland

 

1.     Introduction

a.      Poland is largest European state previous to partitions

b.     Government remained an older political structure and failed to develop modern systems

                                                              i.      No army, no revenues, no administration, and no unity

2.     External interference

a.      1733 War of Polish Succession

                                                              i.      two Polish kings were Germans

                                                            ii.      infighting led to weakness and call for reform and end of liberum veto

                                                          iii.      most notorious outside interest Catherine the Great

1.     1763 Catherine supports Russian puppet in Poland

a.      Stanislas Poniatowski

b.     Declares herself the protector of Polish liberties

c.     Internally divided Poland leaves opportunity for Russian influence the whole country

                                                                                                                                      i.      Division would lessen Russian influence

3.     The first partition

a.      1772 Russia earns a stunning victory against Ottomans

b.     Fear of balance of Power shifting to Russia causes Prussia to propose a partition of Poland (making Prussia contiguous with Brandenburg)

                                                              i.      Russia, Prussia, and Austria agree to partition to avoid war between Russia and Austria

1.     Ottoman Turks are spared (weakening of empire is evident)

2.     Poland is sacrificed

c.     Poles redouble efforts at internal reform (elite class)

                                                              i.      Poniatowski urges reforms as King

1.     New constitution is issued

a.      King is hereditary not elected strengthens monarchy

b.     Reduced the power of the landed gentry

c.     Increased the power of the burghers in the towns

d.      

4.     The second partition

a.      By 1791 fears of the French Revolution spreading to Europe leads Russia to intervene in Polish reform efforts (Jacobins)

b.     1791 Catherine sends in Russian army with support of displaced nobles

c.     1793 Catherine and Prussia take another slice of Poland for each

5.     The third partition

a.      1794 Liberal reform effort led by Thaddeus Kosciuszko

                                                              i.      Proposed the abolition of serfdom

b.     Reform effort is crushed in the wake of counterrevolution

c.     1795 Prussia and Russia invade with armies and divide the remainder of Poland between Prussia, Austria, and Russia

6.     At the time the partitions of Poland were praised as an end of a old nuisance and an affirmation of enlightened rulers (enlightened despots)

a.      War was prevented in Europe by diplomatic means

b.     Replaced anarchy with solid government

c.     Partitions fell around ethnic lines

7.     Burke

a.      Saw the partitions as the beginning of the end for the old order in Europe

                                                              i.      Balance of power was traditionally used to preserve states

                                                            ii.      In Poland balance of power was used to destroy a “state”

8.     Alarming that a state could disappear through cold diplomatic calculation

a.      No established rights seem safe

b.     It is dangerous not to be strong around giant states

                                                              i.      Africa, India, Indo-China

9.     Partitions changed the balance of power overall in Europe

a.      France loses an ally in the east against Germany

b.     Save the Poles becomes the nationalist rallying cry

c.     Three great monarchies are drawn together in common opposition to national liberation

                                                              i.      Agrarian economic base accentuated division between east (reactionary) and west (liberal)

d.     Eastern empires in Europe control territories until WWI

e.      Fall under control of Soviet Union after WWII

f.       1980s Poland re-establishes its national identity